|
Post by tatummcp on Feb 4, 2016 2:15:18 GMT
This poem is very similar to "I, Too" (also by Langston Hughes) in that it shows a person's hope and determination to gain equality and to get what they want. Just like most of Hughes' writing, he wants to reveal the difference in the American Dream for an African-American. He does this by showing that the problem of not being equal has been a problem for generations (hence why the mother has to tell the son about what is going on), but will not improve unless they themselves do something about it. In the poem life has been hard for the mother, but she does not let any of what happened to her bring her down because she will not stop fighting until she gets what she wants. The differences in how the mother is treated and how she reacts to the treatment is seen in the shift when, "But all the time I'se been a-climbin' on / And reachin' landinin's" (8-9). The mother does not give up because she believes in the American Dream and believes that African-Americans will soon be able to take part in this dream sooner or later as long as they continue to fight for it and work hard.
When first looked at, this poem seems to just be about a mother protecting her son from the harsh world around them, but based on our knowledge of Langston Hughes and the time period he wrote in would you say this poem is similar to "I, Too" because of its "hidden meaning"?
|
|
|
Post by cnelson on Feb 5, 2016 0:21:24 GMT
I think that both poems are very similar in meaning, of course they both address the struggles the African Americans faced at that time, but they also both address the hope that is offered by the American dream regardless of all the struggles. The mother in "Mother To Son" and the narrator of "I, Too" are both determined to fight on and overcome suppression because they know that they are worth being recognized. But there is a prominent difference between the narrations of the poem. "I, Too" is in direct first person which gives a much closer internal connection by hearing their individualized thoughts about how they will prove that he/she is "America" too. This revealed the concept of how individuals really must persevere on their own to gain their American dream. In "Mother to Son" the mother is advising the son and explaining the struggles she has faced and essentially instilling hope in him for the future. This portrayed how the black community really banded together and advised each other because they all faced similar struggles. There is a sense of unity in the concept of chasing your American dream in this poem where in "I, Too" it's a much more individual and determined to get to the top on your own. The son still must make the journey up the stairs on his own but his mother is making sure he makes the most of it as she had. So what really is the best way to achieve the American dream; entirely on your own or with a sense of occasional guidance?
|
|